Often referred to as "The Dark Continent," Africa's negative portrayal in the media has reinforced stereotypes and negative views. The media's role as gatekeeper is very evident in their coverage of Africa; as they have great control over the information that gets covered, thus influencing people's views and perceptions. Because of the media's surveillance function, the angle and framing of stories play a large role in the way the audience perceives the issues. The surveillance function makes the media distributors of information, but too many negative stories about an issue can skew the audience's perception. Overwhelming stories of disaster and crime, have the potential to affect people's views of society and what is normal. The prevalence of negative content when it comes to the reporting of Africa by the media, has fueled stereotypes and afro-pessimism.
Origins of Afro-Pessimism
It is important to understand where afro-pessimism stems from, in the discussion of the media's portrayal of Africa. Afro-pessimism is essentially the skepticism of the progress of Africa. It includes notions that Africa is a hopeless and destitute continent, that will be unable to overcome the many challenges it faces.
According to Africanist scholar Rod Chavis, afro-pessimism dates back to pre-colonial times, when Europeans enslaved millions of Africans and exploited them for labor. Europeans characterized Africans as uncivilized barbaric people, who they viewed as inferior. They derived this notion on the basis that the people they encountered in Africa were different from them. This perception has been prevalent throughout history, and has shaped stereotypes and negative perceptions of Africa.
The Media's Role in Fueling Afro-Pessimism
Much of the media's coverage of Africa consists of events such as famine, disease outbreaks, war, poverty, and other negative aspects. The constant reporting of events of this nature by the media, has played a critical role in shaping people's perception of the continent. They ultimately reinforce existing afro-pessimistic ideas and stereotypes.
It is true that Africa is faced with issues of famine and poverty, but western media employs techniques to perpetuate beliefs that Africa is solely comprised of those disastrous aspects.
Danielle Mezzana, delves into the issues of the portrayal of Africa in the media, in her research for Harvard University, that compiles works of many scholars studying this issue. Mezzana cites a study done by Charles Chavis in 1998, that highlight the tactics western media outlets employ to perpetuate negative views of Africa. Chavis boils down the tactics western media outlets use to three components: selection/omission of information, decontextualization, and dramatization.
Omission
When they report on Africa, the media tends to focus specifically on negative aspects, which results in the omission of important information. This behavior by the media frames issues in negative way, which in turn fuels afro-pessimistic views. When they report on disasters or wars, the media uses the tactic of selection to frame the story in a particular manner. This is problematic in many ways, because by omitting important information the media is being unfair in their reporting. They are having an adverse impact on the audience's perception of Africa, and they are a reinforcing the prevalent negative views. Karyn Rothmyer's research found that between September and May of 2010, the ten most read newspapers in the US, had 245 stories about poverty in Africa, but only five had stories about gross domestic product growth. Because these are the most read newspapers, they have credibility with the public which means that they have major impacts on shaping the public's views of Africa.
The media is so intent on highlighting negative aspects of Africa, that they often do not include stories of African prosperity and growth. According to the Bureau of Economic Research, In 2010 the GDP in Africa rose and poverty decreased, yet there were only five articles by major newspapers that discussed this. The media's focus on depicting Africa in a negative light results in the omission of positive things that are happening in Africa.
Decontextualization
Western media also employs the tactic of decontextualization information when reporting on Africa. They fail to provide the context of the information gathered, which has an affect on how the information is presented and perceived. Information is often presented without any historical, social, economic, or political background that would help the audience fully understand the story. Context plays key role in the complete reporting of a story, but since western media fails to provide any background information, the audience is not able to view the full picture of the story. The inability to fully understand the story negatively causes the audience to cling on to their negative views of Africa.
Dramatization
Map Highlighting True Size of Africa |
Western media also dramatizes and exaggerates stories of events in Africa, which reinforce stereotypes and afro-pessimism. This tactic is related to omission, where the media focuses on an area which leads to the omission of important information. When reporting on Africa, the media tends to exaggerate the severity of events to a degree. Instead of finding a balance between highlighting the event without undermining its severity, and dramatizing it to make it seem bigger than it is, the media tends to do the latter, and dramatize events. By reporting from areas that are poverty ridden, and fit the stereotypes people have of Africa, the media exaggerates the economic situation. The media also exaggerates in terms of trying to characterize Africa as one big country, with one group of people living in it. Africa is a continent comprised of 54 countries with people of diverse cultures and ethnicities. The exaggeration of the oneness of Africa by the media fuels the audience's tendency to group Africans together into one category.
These tactics are readily employed by western media outlets when they report on Africa. They are extremely detrimental in presenting an accurate and fair image of Africa. Audiences are constantly seeing these stereotypes presented by the media, which reinforces them in their minds, and fuels afro-pessimism.
NGOs Benefit From Negative Portrayal Africa
Famine, poverty, civil conflict, hunger, and poverty are all ongoing issues in Africa, so media outlets argue that it is their role to address and highlight these issues. Kathryn Rothmyer found that the beneficiaries of the negative portrayal of Africa is ultimately Non-governmental Organizations (NGOs) who provide aid to many African countries. These organizations are dependent on funds from individuals and other organizations, so it is crucial for them to show that there is a need in order to raise funds. In order to do this, they often present the familiar images of starving children covered in flies, and mothers caring for their malnourished children. These images are meant to appeal emotionally to people, to motivate them to donate to the organization.
Although the NGOs are attempting to improve situations for people, their dependence on images that highlight people in harsh conditions, contribute to the media's negative portrayal of Africa. Western audiences see the image of Africa presented to them by NGOs, that use negative images to raise funds, and form perceptions based on them. Since the NGOs are trying to appeal to people, their images often depict people in severe conditions, which leads the audience to believe that that is the condition of majority of Africans.
A journalist for the Gambian newspaper Forayaa, Mariama Demba shares her opinion on the necessity to show harsh conditions in Africa to generate funds for charity organizations.
.
The Africa They Never Show You
Due to the overwhelming negative stories presented about Africa, it is often hard for people to see the beauty in the continent. Africa is a continent rich in culture and natural resources, but western media fails to present this side of Africa.
Underwater Hotel in Tanzania |
Innovative ideas in developing tourism can be seen throughout Africa. One specific example of this would be the Manta Resort in Tanzania, which is an underwater hotel. This hotel gives people a very unique experience of Africa, as they are submerged underwater, and are literally "sleeping with the fishes." Innovative ideas like these attract visitors to Africa, and can help in providing a more positive image of the continent.
Mariama Demba suggests topics and issues western media outlets can highlight in order to present a more fair representation of Africa.
The Media is not Balanced nor Fair in their Coverage of Africa
Although the Africa s plagued with problems such as famine, poverty, and war, the media's sole focus on reporting these problems presents the audience with a distorted view of Africa. There are very few attempts by the media to present stories of positivity and growth in Africa, so the public forms their views of the continent based on the overwhelming negative reports by western media. Instead of intending to perpetuate existing stereotypes, the media should balance out negative stories with stories that highlight positive things that are happening in Africa. Afro-pessimis is deep rooted in society's views of Africa as a hopeless destitute land, and the media only fuels it by focusing on portraying Africa negatively.